Social Signal Consolidation

Is consolidation of social signals possible? Dejan SEO team investigates with a simple test including the rel=”canonical” element.

One of our recent fun graphics got a respectable amount of exposure in social media, however if we load a comment # for that URL the likes, +1’s and Digg counts would reset to zero. At this stage we’re not sure whether this impacts the performance of the canonical page in search results but it would certainly reduce the sharing appeal given low existing social share count numbers.

Sharing with a hash

By canonicalising the URL via <link rel=”canonical” href=”” /> we managed to fix all except Digg:

Canonical Social Buttons

The original numbers did not increase which means that luckily nobody shared a wrong canonical version of this page. Another possibility is that the scores cannot be aggregated across various canonicalise URLs.

Is this important?

Yes of course it is. Imagine arriving on a page and seeing zero shares and seeing hundreds of shares. It’s the social signals that separate poor content from great content these days and can help somebody decide whether they share it further or not.

More importantly, aggregating signals towards one URL means higher score for the canonical page and better performance in places such as StumbleUpon. Surfacing on the first page of major social hubs could cause a sudden surge of visitors and make your content truly viral.

Our Experience

A few years back we launched a viral which (without our knowledge) was reachable from two separate URLs:

Version One:

  • Likes: 4,636
  • Tweets: 143
  • Stumbles: 543,000

Version Two:

  • Likes: 4,636 (Facebook worked it out!)
  • Tweets: 30
  • Stumbles: 181,000

Consolidated version would look much more impressive:

  • Likes: 4,636
  • Tweets: 173
  • Stumbles: 724,000

Canonicalisation has been implemented on the two URLs and we’re waiting to see if it has any impact on the scores we’ve got the results!


Twitter count of 143 has been applied to both URLs and V2 URL’s 30 tweets seem to be lost in limbo. This could be due to the fact that they already counted towards the 143 (prior to canonicalisation) or simply discarded. If it’s the latter then canonicalising URLs is still not as elegant as it could be as the tweets don’t add up as expected.

Helpful Links

John Mueller from Google recommends the following links:

More on the rel=canonical is at
More on the +1 button is at

Comments & Feedback

Jump on the Google+ post for this experiment if you have any experience with this or wish to make a comment.

Dan Petrovic, the managing director of DEJAN, is Australia’s best-known name in the field of search engine optimisation. Dan is a web author, innovator and a highly regarded search industry event speaker.

0 Points

5 thoughts on “Social Signal Consolidation”

  1. Thanks for being so transparent. It’s scary to see that all of that social sharing could be invisible to new visitors. I’d be interested to see an update when you get the results of the acid trip page.

  2. Welist You says:

    Seo Expert is the make a high traffic by Social Bookmarking Search Engine Optimization experts, they help company owners deliver their websites to top rank the search engines. They make certain the website has an social bookmarking that attracts Internet consumers.So Social Signal Consolidation is the best way of Seo Of the hight traffic and liks Of website .Thankyou .

  3. Dejan SEO says:

    Update: Twitter counter was consolidated successfully to 143 tweets on each version. StumbleUpon did not and we don’t expect it to.

  4. Woj Kwasi says:

     How did the Stumble Upon consolidation go?

  5. Interesting. Thanks for the udpate.